Key West and President Trump




by Arnaud Girard…….

Donald Trump is now our President. What might be the effect, good or bad, of the new presidency on our lives, the local environment, businesses, our local school system, our relations with Cuba and more?

  1. Where local economy and new immigration policy collide

Key West’s is booming.  Old fish houses and RV parks with handfuls of employees have been replaced by sprawling restaurants and high class hotels. But this tourist based economy is showing signs of overheating: the value of real estate keeps climbing, creating an unprecedented affordable housing crisis. As a result, scores of locals are forced to leave town. At the same time, new businesses need ever more employees.

And that is where the town could be on a collision course with one of President Trump’s policies. The unspoken truth is that many businesses in Key West are now basing their hiring strategy on an immigration scheme that borders on illegality.They often present themselves as temporary employment agencies. They have flourished in Key West. They are the providers of Eastern European and Central American workers to local restaurants, hotels, and even to contractors. The workers themselves came into the US with real (or fake) “H2B visas” or educational “J visas.” The system seems reassuring to business owners: officially the employees are working for the temp agency, not for the restaurant or the shop owner, who can pretend not to know anything about his foreign workers’ legal status. The problem is the system may have only the appearance of legality: those H2B visas are based on contracts signed outside the US with a specific employer in the US. They do not allow for the placement of employees in permanent positions in a business that is not a party to the contract.

When we asked the immigration services for the list of “H2B visas” issued for Key West businesses we received a suspiciously short list of 90 contracted H2B employees [2014]. Many were linked to a business whose only physical presence was a post office box at Duval Square. Yet some local hotels and restaurants seem to be plugging into an unlimited supply of those indispensable workers.

If the new President makes good on his promise to crack down on illegal immigration and guest worker programs, Key West’s workforce could shrink way below local needs.

The new President is expected to concentrate on the deportation of illegal aliens with criminal records. However, the immigration raids of the Bush era are likely to resume.  A New York Time’s article (Jan 2, 2017) points out that, like Mr. Trump, George W. Bush had promised to deport record numbers of undocumented aliens with criminal records. The immigration service however quickly realized that it couldn’t fulfill those expectations. As it turned out, criminal aliens were simply too difficult to catch to satisfy ambitious deportation quotas. So the Customs and Border Patrol redirected its attention toward an easier target, a much more docile bunch, hiding in plain view. It began raiding homes and businesses to round-up illegal workers. If the same trend imposes itself with the new administration, doing business in Key West could become a lot more difficult, but could also offer more opportunities and higher salaries for locals.

  1. The Sanctuary City debate:

There are a number of reasons why Key West would want to declare itself a “Sanctuary City” as proposed by City Commissioner Jimmy Weekley. Many fear that marriage equality could be revisited (even though Donald Trump himself has not weighed in on the issue.) The City’s relaxed enforcement of marijuana laws apparently conflicts with the views of Trump’s nominee for US Attorney General, Jeff Sessions. (He declared, “Good people don’t smoke marijuana.”) The City could also want to drag its feet in assisting with the enforcement of immigration laws.

Problem is, in his “100 days speech,” Donald Trump made clear his intention to “defund Sanctuary Cities.” That could mean no more federal grants, no more flood insurance for Key West, just to name a few consequences. And once Key West becomes red-flagged as a “Sanctuary City” there is no telling what it would take to get off that black list. A dangerous game.

  1. The Florida Keys environment

We spoke with local resident, Ed Russo. He is the author of a book entitled, Donald J. Trump: An Environmental Hero. Mr. Russo is an environmental expert who works with Donald Trump on development projects that have intricate environmental considerations.  According to Mr. Russo, no one is more environmentally responsible than our new President.

But what happens when the businessman becomes the government?

Donald Trump has positioned himself in favor of an increase of domestic oil exploration and has been skeptical about the ban on offshore drilling. But the perspective of black tides of tar nearing our shores may not be the only problem.

In the past developers in the Keys have run against federal regulations prohibiting new dredging or pollution runoff and mandating strong protections for coastal barrier resource systems and endangered species. However, any such regulation could now be canceled under the new President’s announced trade-off policy: “For any new regulation we will get rid of 2 old ones.” Nobody seems to be able to describe how the trade-off policy is going to work. Can the protection in one area of the country be sold out for some other concern somewhere else? Can “a new regulation” become code word for a pretext to dismantle 2 old obstacles to lucrative real estate development projects? Relaxing federal regulations could indeed result in an explosion of economic activity in the Keys, and/or irreparable harm to our environment.

The future will largely depend on our local government’s willingness to use its own laws to discourage those environmentally dangerous activities that may no longer be kept in check by federal regulations.

  1. Cuba

The effect that a true “opening” of Cuba would have on Key West’s economy is the subject of intense debate. Some think that scores of people will stop here on their way to Cuba, others believe the Miami crowd that comes down on weekends to party on Duval Street would decrease dramatically. No more big weekends. Compared to a long ride to overpriced Key West people might prefer a $200 charter flight to Cuba, with cheaper everything and more novelties.

President Trump has announced that he will put the breaks on Barack Obama’s policy of openness with Cuba. Rex Tillerson, Trump’s pick for Secretary of State, has told the Senate he would personally oppose lifting the embargo. It seems Key West is not going to find out any time soon whether Cuba is a friend or a foe of its tourist economy.

  1. The “white flight” out of Key West’s public schools

In recent years charter schools have been doing well in Key West. They offer an ever-expanding choice of grade levels and curriculum. But critics claim that, in Key West, they cater disproportionally to white students; that they are “cream skimming.” Under the Trump administration this movement is likely to accelerate .

Betsy Devos, Trump’s nominee for Secretary of Education, is not only an advocate for charter schools but also for voucher programs by which parents can use public school money to help pay private school tuition. Trump himself is calling for a 20-billion-dollar school voucher program.

It seems, there may soon be a meeting of the minds between the State of Florida and the new federal government. In this new juncture the status of charter schools in Key West could be considerably improved. For instance, charters could finally receive, not only their share of academic operational funding, but also a corresponding share of infrastructure equity. There is also a push to allow charter schools to form their own school districts, completely independent from the elected school board.

If Key West’s public school system is to survive as a relevant vehicle toward a student’s bright future it’ll need to begin efforts to measure up to the competition.

Conservatives believe they will help rescue traditional public schools by reining in teachers’ unions which are perceived as obstacles to higher accountability and better education. But teachers say the best teachers stick with public schools because charter schools are not unionized and charter schools ultimately will turn to more online courses and lower pay for teachers. Private schools, partly funded by government vouchers, could end up being the only available quality education.

Some people think that increased charter school competition will sound a wake-up call for Key West’s public school administrators. Others think the culture of cronyism is so entrenched in our public schools that the “bubbas” would rather go down with the ship.

Few issues in Key West are in a more desperate need of public mobilization than the struggle for equal opportunities to quality education for all of our children. But don’t hold your breath.

  1. Real Estate

All economists seem to agree that President Trump’s program of deregulation and high spending will cause interest rates to go up. The federal reserve announced it envisions at least 2 prime rate increases this year. This could be good news for the middle-income home buyer since the banks will finally find it profitable to loan money again.

  1. Infrastructure

President Trump is calling for one trillion dollars in new infrastructure. Can we get a bullet train to Miami or an electric turbine generator farm in the Gulf Stream, or a four-lane highway, or a hurricane shelter big enough for all of us, even for tourists, so we’ll never need to evacuate? Whatever our wish list is, our politicians should probably start thinking about how to take advantage of what could be a unique opportunity to improve our local infrastructure.

Facebook Comments

11 thoughts on “Key West and President Trump

  1. A rational and dispassionate analysis, Arnaud. Could you give a lesson to MSNBC?

    The J1 “student” visa program offers multiple abuses. Supposedly offering “practical training,” in fact it offers one-year hard-working Key West vacations to young foreigners who work long hours in dorm housing. They pay no SS tax and minimal federal tax by gaming the system. It would only benefit our US workforce to eliminate this source of workers. The people like me who patronize their high-end employers can easily pay more for honest employment.

    We don’t have to declare ourselves a sanctuary city to effectively be one–it is a null, not an action. Do the right (non) thing, but don’t broadcast it, Jimmy.

    No one can save the reefs. Maybe God, or Gaia.

    Public Ed has been beyond redemption since it was designed by Dewey to produce docile industrial age workbots.

    The President has no effect on interest rates. Takes a book to explain, like the one I wrote in 1994.

    Infrastructure spending can be a home run, unless they give the money to the states and counties to spend themselves, and they instead rathole it again, as they did with Obama’s stimulus (using it to balance budgets and increase reserves, instead of hiring people to do work).

    1. “Infrastructure spending can be a home run, unless they give the money to the states and counties to spend themselves, and they instead rathole it again, as they did with Obama’s stimulus (using it to balance budgets and increase reserves, instead of hiring people to do work).”

      Rick, I think you’ll see a different ballgame this time. Better players.

  2. Agree with most of what you wrote (surprise, surprise?), but no one has said where the feds will get all this money to support infrastructure spending and building up the military, especially since Trump wants to give HUGE tax cuts to the rich (he still thinks trickle-down economics works) and extremely modest tax cuts to the rest – except, of course, for single-parent households who can expect to pay a couple thousand dollars more in taxes and newbie lawyers who’ll also pay more taxes as they find themselves propelled into the top tax bracket via the reduction of brackets from five to three.

    I can suggest that he lay off some of the management from Federal government departments and agencies, and scale back their physical expansion to maybe three regions for all the agencies which exist. USFWS currently has eight regions plus headquarters (they used to say nine regions); USGS went from three regions when I left them in 1999 to eight regions now. Do you know how much new management this has required – from three regional directors et al to eight?

    The Federal government has become extremely top heavy with more chiefs than indians who really do the work. Think of how much money there would be eliminating all those positions, equipment, and buildings, and retiring the dead wood they promoted? We could rebuild every bridge in this nation and pave every road! Trump won’t tackle this – although he should.

    1. My comment was to have been a reply to Rick Boettger’s opinion, but I must have posted it as a stand-alone comment – probably the stress of living through the January 20, 2017, day of infamy. I don’t recall that I have ever disagreed with Naja and Arnaud Girard, whom I admire and congratulate for taking on the Key West/County ‘establishment,’ but I certainly have had fun disputing some posts by my friend and while, male, Republican Rick, a great guy who sometimes leaves me wondering if he fell out of bed and hit his head before he wrote certain pieces. Now, I’m on to the pink pussy march, of which there are 600 worldwide!

      1. Thanks for the uh, props, Animal Lady. Great info on bureaucratic expansion. But, re: where do we get the cash, I wrote a successful book on this in 1994, The Deficit Lie, which explained that at 360-page length. Basically, print it and throw it from helicopters. Or pay contractors. Or even pay useless bureaucrats. Don’t expect me to distill 360 pages into a paragraph. I’m hoping Trump takes on massive “debt” for U.S. as he did for himself, with similar success for his constituency.

        Re my being a registered Republican…that is useful for voting down here. I am a Radical Centrist. I am sometimes to the right of alt-right and Libertarians, and sometimes to the left of Peace and Freedom/Greens. My book pissed off both sides. Neither Repubs or Dems want me to speak at their meetings (I offered to show the upside of Trump at one of their meetings, as printed here post-election, during the primary, and local Repubs ignored me).

        1. I don’t care if you are Republican; I cross party lines when I feel it is right. Do you have a digital copy of your book? If you are right, just think – we don’t need to have poor people or homeless people. I like that!

  3. I strongly believe our new President is going to immensely impress many people, especially since so many are so skeptical. The problem with most is that they rely on media to provide non-biased information, which is a rare entity these days. I’m a rare individual who actually strictly resources to Facts and facts alone. I don’t watch the news or read any biased information. I study law and legal documentation, and then even fact check Those sources since not all legal claims are legit. One thing I like about The Bluepaper is they dig past the surface for facts as well, and like me, aren’t afraid to pass it on.
    Unfortunately many of our President Trump’s plans are being interpreted out of context, and the false media has lots of people terrified and brainwashed into false unnecessary fear of every negative interpretation possible. President Trump has the one priority focus of making life in America great for it’s citizens. People rant about him wanting only to make the rich richer, giving the rich tax breaks and forget the lower classes – which was drilled into them by false media which have been paid by the previous government we had which was focused only on making themselves rich. Reality is the plan President Trump has presented Actually is more benificial for our middle & lower class citizens. He has No motives to profit off of us like our prior con artist who spent most of the past decade vacationing at our expense. (Facts). The proposition I read focuses on Major tax relief for Single individuals making Under $20k per year and couples making Under $40k per year. The propositions I read that focus on immigration is to bring back employment to Our citizens, many of them which were driven into poverty due to being replaced by a cheap working illegal. He focuses on bringing our homeless veterans off the streets. He is a Family man, who doesn’t have any animosity against women – yet another false claim by biased media. I can go on for days, but my point is, I’ve checked the Actual Facts. I’m looking forward to illegals being deported so our struggling Legal Citizens can have gainful employment. I look forward to him shutting down outsourcing so we have to bring Our companies and factories back Here and American companies have to hire American Citizens so We can benefit instead of China or the Phillipines. President Trump has good relations with foreign officials and is Able to have a peaceful understanding that We Need to put Our Country first , which hasn’t been done in too long. Our country has become an international Joke, and now that joke is over and it’s time to move on, move forward, and rebuild. As soon as everyone gets over their sad tantrums not getting their way, marching for our women being oppressed (which is another joke on it’s own since American women have NO clue about oppression)… but as soon as these people wake up they can stop being part of the problem and start being part of the solution & it Will be Great! ?

    1. Anyone can fact check, but if you choose to show only the portions which support your mindset and ignore the reality of the entire package, it does little good.

  4. Boy, I wonder what all these Trump fools would say now. Trump’s Failure Friday is a new set of disasters. Trump has not won on ANYTHING. Bullshit executive orders and stupid tweets. A White House that is a disaster. Obvious collusion with the Russians. Trump is a pathological liar and as one Republican was heard to say, “Trump is crazy.” A president who is a sexual predator. A president who relives his electoral college win and constantly attempts to justify his election in virtually every speech… even before the CIA memorial wall and the Boy Scouts. You know why he is always talking about it, it is because Trump knows full well that he is president because of the Kremlin and has to constantly convince us and himself that he is not a Russian stooge. He gives virtually the same political speech every time he gives one. Of all the things he could have said to the Boy Scouts. What a freaking moron.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.