by Arnaud and Naja Girard

A wrecking ball crashed through the City’s defense to the Eimers police brutality case on Friday.  At a scheduled deposition Chief Lee was expected to provide bureaucratic information about the City’s procedures and policies in the wrongful death case filed by the Eimers family against the City of Key West and 13 police officers.

But instead he spent over two hours freefalling into a seemingly endless pit opened by allegations of  “perjury” committed by his officers.  At issue was the surprise new bystander video that showed up this week from Colombia.   Unlike the first video, it shows Eimers arrest all the way to the point of his death.  A fact that turns out to be devastating to the somewhat creative and more favorable stories cooked up by some of the officers.

“Sir, we’ve gone to the trouble, in preparation for various motion practice,” said attorney Robert McKee, “of taking every question and answer of your officers who were under oath and every time their answers were not what the video showed. There are pages and pages of it”…. and down we went.

The Walking Dead Story

The new video completely contradicts one point nearly all of the officers have insisted upon:  They said Eimers only went limp after they tried to lift him and walk him to the police cruiser.  The video however doesn’t show officers attempting to lift Mr. Eimers up.  He was on his belly, hands shackled behind his back, legs hobbled.  When officers realized he had stopped breathing, they untied him, rolled him onto his back and within two minutes began CPR. He left on a stretcher.   Yet strangely this “rising to his feet,” is one story most officers swore to in their depositions, sometimes  with minute detail,

Officer Gustavo Medina :

Medina: “He was resisting the entire time until we lifted him up…. When we brought him up is when he went unconscious.”

Q: :“How was Mr. Eimers lifted?”

Medina: :I put my arms under his belly.”

Q:  Was he in the prone position when he was being lifted?”

Medina: “Yes.”

Officer Gary Lee Lovette:

Lovette: “He was still breathing and fighting when we raised him.”

Officer DelValle:

DelValle: “When we lifted him up he was struggling to get to his feet.  He leaned forward.  I saw his legs moving to try to stand up.”

Officer Gabriel Garrido:

Garrido: “We attempted to lift him out of the sand before noticing he was unconscious. I recall I lifted him by his shoulders. We noticed he was unconscious while we lifted him.”

Officer Nicholas Galbo:

Galbo: “At that point he was sitting up.  He was leaned up.”

Q: On his butt?

Galbo: “Yes.”…  “We decided to stand Mr. Eimers up and walk him over to the patrol car.”

The reader can verify that the new video doesn’t show any of that happening.  Eimers was found to be unconscious while lying prone in the sand, rolled over onto his back, then treated with CPR.

So why this insistence on representing that Eimers was nearly able to stand up even though he was already virtually dead? Arguably these creative stories have been essential to the defense. They enabled the Medical Examiner to rule out asphyxiation: How could Charles Eimers have died smothered in the sand if he was still alive when he was lifted up off the sand where there was plenty of air to breathe?

The Peaceful Portrait Story

“Blood is not good,” attorney Darren Horan told us, “blood in the arrest of an unarmed subdued old man spells excessive force.”  According to FDLE’s Kathy Smith and sworn testimony by some of the officers, Eimers had no blood on his face and “only a light dusting of sand.”

“I didn’t see at any time Mr. Eimers face planted in the sand,” swore Officer Delvalle during his deposition two week ago.  But on Friday both Chief Donie Lee and Sergeant Joseph Tripp, of Internal Affairs, were put face to face with the gruesome photos of Charles Eimers’ showing his head bloodied and all caked up with sand.

From Officer Galbo’s deposition:

Q:  Did you look at his [Eimers] face.?

A:  “Yes.”

Q:  “Was there any sand?”

A:  “No.”

Q:   “Was there any blood?”

A:  “No.”

Same with Officer DelValle:

Q:  Was there sand on his face?

A:  “There was residual sand around his nose.”

Chief Lee had to agree with the Eimers family attorneys, “It appears that he had sand on his face.”

Q:  Why does his face appear different here than on the photo taken by officer Stevens?

A:  I don’t know.

Q:  Did Officer Stevens clean up his face before taking the photo?

A:  I don’t know.

Q:  Aren’t your officers making false statements under oath? Aren’t they guilty of perjury?   Are you the one in charge?

Sometimes it’s not that great to be the Chief.

But there was more.

The Time Machine Story

There’s the problem of the man who was in two places at the same time. Motorcycle cop Officer Randall Hartle was not there or rather according to the CAD report he did not arrive on scene until long after it was all over.

Now, according to KWPD, these CAD reports represent an incorruptible system of data collection. Yet in this new video Officer Hartle appears mysteriously on scene at a time when the CAD readout clearly shows that he would not arrive until over 20 minutes later. Does someone have a time machine at KWPD or was the data tampered with?

A similar controversy involves Officer Gary Lee Lovette’s Taser.  Three civilian witnesses testified they saw or heard a Taser being fired.  Officer Wanciak testified she saw Officer Lovette placing the Taser on Eimer’s upper back.  The video shows Lovette’s arm arguably in position to Tase Eimers, yet the data report collected for that particular Taser shows that it was fired 2 hours after the incident with Eimers – at 10:35 am – for 5 sec.

On the video Wanciak is seen making a call to dispatch. She is assigned code #P48.  Dispatch CAD data indicates that a transmission from Officer P48 came in informing that Eimers “was Tased”, but officer Wanciak testified on Friday that she didn’t make such a report.  Then, 2 hours later another CAD entry states “not Tased” even though no investigation has yet been conducted regarding the officers’ Taser devices.

Needless to say Eimers family lawyers had a field day with their cover-up allegations.

The Mysterious Scream Story

The new video also supported the testimony of a tourist from Maryland, who reported having heard Charles Eimers yell “Ow! You’re hurting me!”  This complaint is heard loud and clear in the new video.  The Chief admitted that the voice was not that of any of his officers and that it had to be Eimers.  FDLE’s Kathy Smith claimed in her investigative report that the “Ow!” heard on Officer Medina’s external dashcam mic had come from Officer Gabriel Garrido who had gotten his finger stuck in the handcuff.

There is now some solid proof that the officers escalated and incited resistance by hurting the old man and carelessly allowed him to suffocate in the sand.

By 6:00 pm, when the depositions ended, the accumulation of lies that had been exposed that day had worked a nauseous daze over those of us in attendance.  The crowded conference room emptied out with attendees barely looking at each other.  More depositions are scheduled for next week.

Stay tuned.


To access all Blue Paper coverage on the death of Charles Eimers click here.

Facebook Comments


    1. Lee could put everyone of them on administrative leave, without pay, and let the police union try to override him in mediation, arbitration, or a court. Lee should have done that as soon as the blue paper broke the case with the first bystander’s video.

  1. I am not surprised at all. I have had some personal experience with the Key West police department and I know how they lie and cover it up with more lies and abuse.

  2. I have had enough of the inaction by our POS Mayor and Commissioners. I called CBS News today and implored them to do a follow-up piece on the murder since the latest video surfaced. I also called the U.S. Department of Justice to do an investigation of all those involved in the cover-up. I can’t remember when I’ve been more pissed off about anything in my lifetime and I won’t rest until all involved answer for what happened. I read in the fishwrap this morning about the David Fernandez lawsuit. Has our Mayor and Commissioners possibly have represented us worse than they have presented thus far? Everything they touch turns to crap. How much money will we allow them to cost us taxpayers without us doing something about it?

  3. I’m still waiting to hear from Craig Cates, Margaret Romero, Tony Yaniz and others who made public statements backing KWPD in the Eimers murder. They were quick to show support but are now strangely silent. I don’t see how anyone can continue to support them since the latest video surfaced. The cops involved obviously knew they killed Charles Eimers or why the need to lie about the facts? It’s also very disturbing KWPD, FDLE and Catherine Vogel could have gotten this latest video but chose not to. That tells me the FIX was in and the outcome of the Grand Jury was already determined. KWPD cops lied to the Grand Jury. If you or I did that we would be behind bars. Why hasn’t anything happened to those lying thugs? I sense there is now a “circling of the wagons” by KWPD, FDLE and our State Attorneys Office.

  4. One last chance. We have heard testimony from all the officers involved. We have seen the FDLE report and the Coroner’s report, the Grand Jury report at the hands of the State Attorney and her office, and we have all seen several videos relating to this ‘situation’. We have one last report to come before this goes to trial and costs all we taxpayers a fortune. Chief Lee had said he was waiting for the FDLE report before he conducted his own investigation – how is that report coming? Any honest person who watched these videos and compared them to police testimony would agree there are serious discrepancies. Pictures and video do NOT lie. Stories told by people can be just that ‘stories’. It is a shame NO ONE from the city has stepped up and said a word other than ‘we can’t talk because of the pending lawsuit’. A statement such as ‘we’re sorry Eimer’s family for your loss’ OR ‘we acknowledge there are many discrepancies between videos and police statements, we want to assure the public we will see that honesty and truth will prevail and that you CAN have faith in us – your elected leaders’. But the silence continues. The problem most of us have is that silence gives consent, in other words they become part of the problem and coverup (I use this term because of the consistent, INCONSISTENCY of what we see on the video and what we have been told by police officers, coroner (does it seem odd he retired or left office right after his report?), the FDLE, the State Attorney and the Grand Jury). Wonder who is going to ‘retire’ next rather than stand and face the truth? No wonder the people of Ferguson don’t trust their government or the Grand Jury! Though personally I don’t think those people wanted the ‘truth’, they wanted the blood of what I think was a police officer doing his job and scared for his life – just my opinion. But you can understand public distrust when you see what’s happening in Key West.
    So where do we stand with Chief Lee’s internal investigation? Chief Lee if you are reading this I want to speak directly to you. Sadly, the people of Key West have either lost faith, are losing faith, or seriously question that they can trust our city and our police force as a whole (I know there ARE good and honest officers on the force, but I will not say that about all of them). You, Chief Lee, are probably our last hope for someone to come out and conduct an honest investigation. As far as I know you have not made any statements that are untrue – someone may respond to my posting and say I am wrong, but of all the false statements and reports Ive seen so far, I don’t believe you have made any of those. You, Chief Lee, have read all of the reports and seen the video, you are a reasonable and intelligent man, and you know there are discrepancies and problems. Someone needs to step up and be truthful. It could be the mayor, a commissioner, a police officer (you should be protected as a whistle blower), or you Chief Lee. Not only has a man died, but we have lost our faith, AND, this is going to cost we taxpayers a FORTUNE. I for one am sick of our tax dollars being wasted – by the millions. If our elected politicians are not going to protect our good name, our safety and well-being, and our financial budget/reserves we have to do something about that. Chief Lee, you may be our last hope with your internal investigation. My question to you is – Will you become part of the solution, or remain part of the problem?

  5. I’d like to know if the ‘wheels of justice’ allow for a new grand jury investigation, which would include indicting all of these cops on perjury charges as well as charging them with murder?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this. See our Privacy Policy here: